Evaluation of Eight Fresh Dog Food Delivery Services Reveals Top Three Recommendations

A variety of companies offer fresh dog food made from whole, gently cooked ingredients. Selecting the best option for your pet can be a daunting task. This guide evaluates eight fresh dog food delivery services, with trials conducted by myself and other reporters who tested these products with their dogs to ensure consistent quality. I also consulted two board-certified veterinary nutritionists and a food safety expert to gain insights into canine nutrition and the safety of fresh pet food.

The leading brands in fresh dog food are recognized for expertly formulated recipes, strict quality control, convenient delivery, and attractive discounts for new subscribers. All foods should meet the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) standards for complete nutrition. Veterinarians recommend selecting brands that follow the Global Nutrition Guidelines published by the World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA).

It’s important to note that fresh pet food isn't definitively healthier than our recommended options for canned and dry food. A study conducted by researchers at the University of Minnesota's Urolith Center identified a new type of canine bladder stone associated with choline bitartrate, an ingredient found in some fresh foods, including those from JustFoodForDogs, The Farmer’s Dog, and Nom Nom. If your dog has these specific stones, consult your veterinarian about avoiding foods with choline bitartrate in favor of options from brands like Hill's or Royal Canin.

**Top Recommendations:**

JustFoodForDogs has a variety of options, offering six fresh frozen recipes and four shelf-stable meals. Prices start at $1.90 per day for small dogs. New customers can receive 50% off their first auto-ship order and 5% off subsequent orders.

This brand is our top choice because of its extensive protein options, adherence to WSAVA guidelines, and validated AAFCO feeding trials, confirming the nutritional integrity of their meals. JustFoodForDogs provides an array of frozen and shelf-stable recipes suitable for all life stages, along with specialized diets for health issues like skin sensitivities and joint support.

The Farmer’s Dog stands out as our budget pick, with prices starting at $2.24 per day for small dogs and a 50% discount on the first two weeks. Known for affordability, it offers seven recipe options, having validated its recipes through AAFCO trials and partnered with veterinary nutritionists. Its grain-inclusive and grain-free options cater to diverse dietary needs.

Freshpet Delivery is highlighted for feeding training and puzzle activities, making it ideal for pet owners looking for convenience. It offers soft, nugget-like food that starts at $1.48 per day for small dogs, with a 50% discount on the first five weeks. This brand provides a versatile texture that works well in puzzle feeders and for training, while meeting WSAVA and AAFCO nutritional standards.

Other brands evaluated include Nom Nom, Open Farm, and The Pets Table, which all meet AAFCO standards but didn't rank as highly in our testing. Each has unique features, though some lack full-time veterinary nutritionists or detailed recipe transparency. For proper nutrition, ensure any food meets AAFCO and WSAVA guidelines and consult a veterinarian for personalized advice regarding your dog's dietary needs.