On September 23, 2026, the New York-based cat rescue nonprofit Itty Bitty City Kitties announced a new adoption policy barring supporters of the MAGA movement from adopting kittens. The decision quickly sparked significant backlash, particularly from conservative circles, and garnered a response from PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals).
Read More
Samantha Knox, the rescue’s director, defended the policy on social media, stating that their commitment to animal welfare required ensuring homes for kittens that avoid any political affiliations associated with harm or cruelty. One post on the organization's Instagram highlighted their stance with a caption stating, "If your politics involve racism, bigotry, dehumanizing immigrants, or cheering on cruelty toward vulnerable people, please kindly f**k right off."
In an interview with Fox News Digital, Knox emphasized that their vetting process focuses on applicants’ conduct and ethical alignment rather than political party affiliation. She clarified, "Itty Bitty City Kitties does not screen or reject applicants based on registered political party affiliation." However, the organization asserts the right to reject applications based on values or actions that do not align with their safety and welfare standards.
Criticism of the policy intensified, with many users on social media arguing that animals do not care about their owners' political beliefs. Some users expressed concerns that the rescue was prioritizing political statements over the welfare of the animals. PETA's founder Ingrid Newkirk urged the organization to reconsider its policy, arguing that homeless animals require loving homes regardless of their adopters’ political views.
Despite the criticism, Knox continued to receive support from some community members who felt the policy was justified for the safety of the kittens. She later shared instances of hostility directed at her via messages, noting that many contained offensive language. Knox reiterated her stance, declaring that compassion and ethical concern guide their adoption process.
The situation has led to widespread discussions about the intersection of animal welfare and political beliefs, with Knox stating that her organization would remain steadfast in its mission to protect animals from potential harm.